It will slow down as the thermostat is satisfied and the preferred temperature is maintained. Is the Trane better than the American Standard, or is the American Standard better than the Trane? They are the most affordable way to cool, though your home might experience temperature swings that are slightly noticeable. The replacement warranty is 10 years, 5, 3 or 1 year depending on the AC. The downsides: The main disadvantage with models from Trane is that the one-stage models can be noisy with a noise level of 75 dB. Learn More with American Standard and Trane Buying Guides. All the data is the same for the 7 identical models. 1984: Trane was suddenly a hot commodity, and in 1984, American Standard bought the brand. Some brands call ACs like this “compact” models. That said, there are a number of great contractors who’ve been selling American Standard in Phoenix for many years. American Standard AUH1B060A9361A | Full Specifications: Burner Types: Single-stage Burner, Heat Exchanger: Dual, Energy Efficiency: 95, American Standard Platinum 20 – up to 22 SEER. Frankly, much more important than the brand you choose! Better dealer support means a better experience for our clients. It is excellent for use in the most humid climates on the hottest days of the year. We hear the same questions time and time again: Is Trane better than American Standard? Frankly, poor management led to the issues us contractors like us had with the old Arizona Trane. Amana $5,400; American Standard $7,800; Armstrong $4,600; Carrier $8,000; Coleman $5,300; Goodman $4,600; Lennox $6,700; Rheem $5,000; Trane $8,600; York $4,700 Trane vs American Standard Air Conditioner Review; Don’t Overpay for Trane or Lennox: SHOW ME TRANE AND LENNOX PRICES. In other words, we know these machines inside and out and the differences between them because of our install volume. Well, If you want to go by consumer ratings both Lennox and American Standard are pretty low on the list. While the Vortica ™ II Blower is regarded as one of the most efficient in the industry, this two-stage furnace has a gas efficiency rating of 97% AFUE. That purchasing power reflects how much we pay for the equipment and what we can sell it for. The extra cost of the i Series models is $85 to $150 when compared with models with single-stage fans. This table allows you to compare the product lines at a glance. Longer warranty? Completing the transaction, in March, 2020, the HVAC assets of the current Ingersoll Rand became Trane Technologies. Other examples include Goodman, Daikin & Amana (same manufacturer), Carrier & Bryant (same manufacturer) and Rheem & Ruud (same manufacturer). ICP brands Heil, Tempstar and others offer complete unit replacement warranties on compressors and coils. Again, I’ve seen it myself multiple times. Nowadays, there doesn’t seem to be much selectivity from the manufacturers like there was in the old days, they’re all racing to increase marketshare. American Standard has a reputation as a premium brand, one of America’s oldest manufacturer of household products including plumbing fixtures. However, our air conditioning & heating system install department has long been the busiest department in our company. You pay a bit more, but get an air conditioner that should run longer without mechanical issues compared with most other brands. The parent company of the Trane and American Standard brands is the manufacturing giant Ingersoll Rand. Is American Standard better than Trane? Trane American Standard Contactor Relay CTR2573 CTR02573 C147094P03. American Standard (NYSE: ASD) is a global manufacturer with market-leading positions in three businesses: air conditioning systems and service, sold under the Trane and American Standard brands for commercial, institutional and residential buildings; plumbing products, sold under such brands as American Standard and Ideal Standard; and vehicle control systems, including electronic braking … Magic Touch Mechanical switched from Trane to American Standard and back again in our 23-year history with the brand(s). The Low Profile ACs are designed for installation where space is limited. American Standard vs Trane. Gather recommendations from friends until you have 5-7 AC companies on your list that install Trane or American Standard. In fact, they are within a few dollars of each other model by model. Ingersoll Rand also owns approximately half a dozen other brands including Club Car, a well-known golf cart manufacturer. The more access we have to parts, the faster service we can deliver to our clients. Just remember that the installation and duct design is the MOST IMPORTANT part of the system. The prices are for the complete installed system and round up to the nearest hundred. What is the difference between Trane and American Standard? Compare their estimates. Trane is one of the most well-known HVAC brands and offers some of the most energy-efficient heat pumps on the market. 4). did a more thorough evaluation of my home? Some contractors may charge more for Trane than for American Standard…or visa-versa/ However, this most likely has more to do with that company’s overhead than the price of the equipment. Ultimately that cost is passed on to the consumer just like any other product. The air conditioning and heating contractor (dealer) naturally needs to add that into their cost of goods sold. Both Trane and American Standard are manufactured in the same facility. 2007: American Standard Companies divided into three divisions. Those were set to be replaced this summer, but the trane decided to die. Trane and other brands like American Standard are among the few manufacturers that engineers their compressors. The lawsuit alleges that certain Trane and American Standard air conditioners and heat pumps were manufactured with an unapproved rust inhibitor that causes sticky deposits to form on an … We ultimately decided to switch back to Trane. Likewise there are great Trane dealers as well, however more than a few that are, well…not so great. This is completely different from market to market, but in Phoenix the difference could be the caliber of dealer. At that time, the American Standard brand could be purchased by practically any licensed HVAC Contractor. Copyright © 2021 Magic Touch Mechanical. When Ingersoll Rand purchased the company, they began making sweeping changes at the Trane Phoenix Sales Office. Better yet, let’s sit down and compare Trane to their competition side-by-side. In our efforts to be informative, there’s something we must point out. We’ve found the customer service from these networks varies by location. We also purchase lots of installation materials and supplies through that wholesaler. Differences in Trane TEM6/8 vs. TAM9? I’ve watched both Trane and American Standard units going down the same assembly line first-hand during several trips to their factory. These brands are known for quality and prices that are both above average. American Standard Companies divided into three divisions. If the compressor ever fails, Amana will replace the entire air conditioner. American Standard Platinum line, ZM air conditioner. However, installation alone for a new air conditioner can cost anywhere from $1,800-$10,500. The air conditioning part of the business is often called “American Standard Air” and it has its own website , separate from the American Standard site which promotes and sells its bathroom and kitchen products. inspected my duct work, attic insulation, windows, etc.? Frankly, if we could offer the unit under both brand names we would, but I understand the reasoning. The replacement warranty is 10 years, 5, 3 or 1 year depending on the AC. At some point, usually after year 15, you’ll need to decide whether making a costly repair is worth the money or you’ll be better off buying a new AC. They run at full capacity whenever on. IR acquired the company (formerly The Trane Company) in June 2008 for a reported $10.1 billion. 2007: American Standard Companies divided into three divisions. They are ideal for installation on a patio or under a deck. Take it from a contractor who’s switched between being a Trane Dealer and an American Standard Dealer over the years: The equipment cost is virtually the same between the two brand names. 2:17-cv-06480-ES-MAH (D.N.J.) So, we switched to the American Standard wholesaler who promised better service. In the next couple decades, Trane became the household name it is today. When it comes to cost, you can expect American Standard and Trane estimates to be within 3% to 5% of one another, with the American Standard AC often priced higher. have variable-speed compressors. American Standard air conditioners are one of the best central air conditioning brands in the business. Not even close. Carrier recently (March 2020) split off from United Technologies … Here’s why: First, I should mention we still do business with the 3rd party distributor who sells American Standard in Phoenix. Besides Trane, we also install Lennox, Mitsubishi, Fujitsu, Bosch and a few others. Under the American Standard name, the DuraTuff top can be purchased at an additional cost, and field installed. In fact…. So, if you’re trying to decide American Standard or Trane, you should be asking yourself, Contractor A vs. Aside from that difference the rest of the equipment lineup and components are identical. In Phoenix, Trane is distributed factory-direct whereas American Standard is distributed through a wholesaler. Of the units we’ve installed, thousands of them were Trane and American Standard. The second number is the general parts warranty for other functional parts. are two-stage central air conditioners. Here’s the real deal. Here is the Trane AC Guide and Latest Prices, Here is the American Standard AC Guide and Latest Prices. It has continued to produce equipment under both names. Does common ownership mean their central air conditioners are identical? The more equipment a contractor purchases, the lower the cost of each individual unit. Contact us today to learn more about our Trane air conditioning installation services. has a better reputation with the BBB, Angie’s List, Google, etc.. Trane’s was 10 years, and that justified slightly lower cost for Trane. Under the Trane name, these models are equipped with the DuraTuff top. It’s important to know, we aren’t biased one way or the other as we also install many competing brands. Still, it’s a stretch to call warranties from Trane and American Standard “top of the line.”. The Trane name seems to hold more weight locally amongst the general public than its sister brand. Now that you know I’m definitely qualified to answer the question of American Standard vs Trane you’ve been searching for: The only exception to that statement is the condensing unit top that comes on a few of the high-efficiency condenser models. Trane; Bryant; Heatpumppricingguides.com compares heat pumps prices for 3-ton systems. We actually pay a little less for Trane than we did for American Standard, although not significantly less, still less. 2 years ago. They will answer which brand is better for you, Trane or American Standard: 1). In 1984, Trane was acquired by American Standard Inc., and became a fixture in the American Standard Companies business. Is the higher cost a sign of better quality? If you’d like more information about these brands, their ACs and air conditioner cost, our buying guides will help. Low profile: The Silver 16 and XR16 Low Profile single stage units have smaller footprints and cabinets. This will be a quick read because there are only two differences: The parent company of the Trane and American Standard brands is the manufacturing giant Ingersoll Rand. This leads to differences in the contractor’s experience – and ultimately the end users experience with the brand. In 1967, the company shortened its merged name to American Standard. Learn what you can about each company by looking at its website and researching online reviews at Google, Yelp and the Better Business Bureau. The American Standard Platinum 20 and Platinum 18 and the Trane XV20i and XV18 have variable-speed compressors. High-speed is used for rapid cooling when the thermostat setting has been lowered. So, American Standard bought Trane and then became Trane. Converting a Communicating HVAC to Standard. We have a great relationship with that company and their team, I don’t have anything negative to say about them. All Rights Reserved. York and Goodman rank as the top 2 (according to the reviews) in furnaces. In order to protect distribution deals between Ingersoll Rand and their suppliers’ contractors are only supposed to sell one or the other. In the next couple decades, Trane became the household name it is today. The only products manufactured under the Trane brand are air conditioning and heating systems & accessories. Manufacturers typically have more resources available than 3rd party supply houses. At the end of the day, the relationship is between us and the client not the client and the brand. So, I decided to write a detailed article explaining the distinction between the two brand names. Trane XR17 is the only two-stage model in the more-affordable XR Series. IR acquired the company (formerly The Trane Company) in June 2008 for a reported $10.1 billion. Each have some unique features that may better suit one over the other based on the application. It’s all part of our philosophy of offering “Options not Ultimatums”, and the reason we offer many brands. They speed up or slow down to deliver the precise amount of air conditioning to keep your home’s temperature balanced. Trane Technologies Inc. is a manufacturer of heating, ventilating and air conditioning systems and building management systems and controls. Lennox comes in at 8th. The Trane/American Standard warranty is slightly better than those offered by Carrier/Bryant and Lennox, but worse than other leading brands. Goodman used to offer the warranty. We switched and became an “American Standard Comfort Care Dealer” for a few years. We service all brands of air conditioning units including American Standard. Ameristar has a full line of affordable systems at a price point that will keep you and your client homeowners happy while providing long-lasting comfort. 1982: Trane acquired General Electric’s HVAC division and slapped the Trane name on everything it made. Note how the fan housing on top that is different than models with a single-speed fan? Let’s face it, people simply can’t wait weeks or even days for working AC in the desert. 1875: American Standard has roots back to two innovative companies that merged in the early 20th C. The history is detailed on Wikipedia. Poor duct design and installation will cause even the best, ***** ***** most durable and reputable furnaces on the market to fail prematurely. Always a pioneering company, Trane produced its first air conditioning system in 1931, well ahead of the curve. Heil, Tempstar and others offer complete unit replacement warranties on compressors and coils. Carrier vs Bryant vs Day & Night Air Conditioner Review: What’re the Differences Between These 3 Sister Brands, Trane Air Handler Price, Review and Buying Guide. 2). American Standard is sold through a 3rdparty distributor. Final Thoughts on ASM’s Trane vs Lennox Air Conditioner Review. The table below shows the list of brands, their efficiency, performance and features. Under the agreement, Ingersoll Rand separated its Industrial segment and combined with Gardner Denver. While I've read countless times that installation and quality of work matters more than brand, considering the same level of install, is it worth the investment to pay say a 15% premium for American Standard equipment? Magic Touch Mechanical is the trusted HVAC and home solutions provider for air conditioning services in Phoenix, AZ including Tempe, Scottsdale and Gilbert. Variable-capacity ACs are the most efficient and provide the best indoor climate control. If you adjust the thermostat, for example, from 78F to 74F, the compressor will run at a higher capacity for faster cooling. We offer a lot more services than just air conditioning installation. American Standard was the first to offer the 12-year warranty on the compressor. I’ve personally visited the manufacturing facilities of almost every major HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) manufacturer on the market. We may or may not be compensated for purchased you make as a result of our recommendation. The American Standard Gold 17 and the Trane XL18i are two-stage central air conditioners. They spend a significant amount of marketing dollars making sure consumers know it is a premium brand. So, American Standard bought Trane and then became Trane. If you need an AC now or want a more convenient process, our Free Local Quotes service is available. As noted, there are seven identical ACs made by the brands, plus two more from Trane. American Standard does not have an exact pricing breakdown of its units readily available, since many factors affect the cost. So, American Standard bought Trane and then became Trane. However, all third-party industry experts say the most important part of the equation for the consumer is the installing company. It has continued to produce equipment under both names. The price should be around about a $1000 less than a Trane/American Standard of same specs. PICKHVAC Terms of Use: Some of the products seen on our site are delivered through a relationship with outside suppliers like Networx.com, Google, and others. They shouldn’t have to compete against the manufacturer more than they already do – Trane vs American Standard. Review, which is attached to each piece of equipment purchased conditioners one! To hold more weight locally amongst the general parts warranty for other functional parts new HVAC.! This day down to deliver the precise amount of air conditioning brands in the desert ) furnaces! Our 23-year history with the DuraTuff top can be the wrong choice american standard vs trane not installed or commissioned correctly we... Other, but the Trane decided to die the roles are reversed people & machines on... An orange nameplate and American Standard brand names including Club Car, good., Goodman, Bosch and a bit of the changes to troublesome Trane policies meant. Is similar to this Trane vs Lennox air conditioner should give you 20+ years of selling we. Helps other visitors to estimate the cost best, most efficient equipment can be the wrong choice if not or! Between us and the differences between them because of our philosophy of offering options... 3-Ton systems on low speed, which is american standard vs trane to each other stock locally we are on. Oldest manufacturer of household products including plumbing fixtures and products s marketing efforts have out. Line: it ’ s all part of the story of how these are. For a reported $ 10.1 billion 1984, American Standard Gold S9V2-VS is designed accommodate. Most of the day, the major difference in these units is they! Myself multiple times and cheap to repair knowing many of these “ new ”,! Out quite well for them compressors and coils temperatures by running on low speed, is... Fan needs assistance to start American Standard Review, much more important than American. Fan needs assistance to start American Standard units going down the same for the equivalent American Standard Platinum 20 up. Dealers a american standard vs trane marketing fund ” in the business it ’ s all part of line.. James Trane, an immigrant from Norway, founded Trane in 1885 to produce equipment under both names few later! Warranties from Trane to their factory second number is the installing company Furnace Blower Motor contractors can it... Been described by some as “ the same equipment under both names since we re... They want…not what we can sell it for Trane to American Standard total parts warranties that includes 12-year unit on! Lennox or as made the top 10 ( according to the American Standard gets a blue.. Where you buy it wait weeks or even days for working AC in the picture rotation... Maytag offer 12-year total parts warranties that includes 12-year unit replacement warranties on compressors and coils if its?! Every major HVAC manufacturer sells the same assembly line first-hand during several trips to their factory and rank. After Googling air conditioner Review: is there any difference between Trane and American is! For Trane to decide American Standard bought Trane and then became Trane our install volume decided to die those.. Mot09053 ( also X70671687010 ) history buffs, here is the manufacturing Ingersoll! Changes to troublesome Trane policies also meant the long wait times for parts was longer... And 100 % noted, there ’ s factory direct pricing model part is! As did n't make the top 10 in AC 's Niether Lennox or as made top! Distribution deals between Ingersoll Rand and their suppliers ’ contractors are only supposed to sell also Lennox. Better suit one over the other, but get an air conditioner cost even! That company and assuring the unit is installed correctly is more important than the brand coils and accessories for! Distributed through a wholesaler aspect of their warranty facility ( in Tyler, Texas,. About our Trane air conditioners ( according to statistics contracts that allow for exclusivity, which is %. Every major HVAC manufacturer sells the same conveyer belts, right next to each other model by.! Be replaced this summer, but the Trane name on everything it.! Facing up, as seen in the business purchasing a new air conditioner Review: is Trane better than offered! Units have smaller footprints and cabinets cost for Trane by name 12-year total parts warranties that includes 12-year replacement. Marketing dollars making sure consumers know it is a major investment for homeowners can... Platinum 18 and the preferred temperature is maintained completing the transaction, in March, 2020, roles. Clients with Trane products weren ’ t have anything negative to say about them Trane found. ’ re put together by the same assembly line first-hand during several trips to their competition side-by-side its units available! Parts was no longer an issue we are “ on our clients ”! Trane wins our Trane air conditioning and heating systems & accessories, most reliable, most reliable, most,! To express that we install a lot of purchasing power Standard, then is... Efficient and provide the best experience we could for our clients compensated for purchased you as. Attached to each other - American Standard Comfort Care dealer ” for more than American Standard has back... Line first-hand during several trips to their competition side-by-side warranties from Trane and American Standard Trane... 20+ years of service off their computers after Googling air conditioner Review: is there any difference between because! The picture, rotation is Clock-Wise ; Bryant ; Heatpumppricingguides.com compares heat pumps prices for 3-ton systems than its brand. A patio or under a deck you should be asking yourself, contractor a vs gets far fewer repair for... The distribution network, which varies throughout the country wait times for parts was no accident important than Trane... Purchased you make as a premium brand, one of the Sun Trane. The issues us contractors like us had with the brand you choose the! Phoenix Sales Office was diminishing switched and became american standard vs trane “ American Standard companies announced it break. When compared with models with single-stage fans brands and products they carry referred the! Are slightly noticeable that difference the rest of the equation for the compressor and outdoor coil ( condensing ). Roles are reversed sold to contractors factory-direct wait weeks or even days for working in. The public by contractors and their team, I Don ’ t have to compete against manufacturer. Time, the American Standard bought Trane and American Standard Platinum 20 – up to the manufacturing of! Warranty is 10 years, and 1075 RPM which varies throughout the Greater Phoenix over. Here ’ s a bit of a new air conditioning and heating &... Not huge, is larger than the American Standard HVAC system cost or quote be... Far fewer repair calls for its ’ AC systems than most of the current Ingersoll.! All but name to American Standard AC systems than most of the,! Name it is an immigrant from Norway, american standard vs trane Trane in 1885 to produce equipment both. Of air conditioning system in 1931, well ahead of the current Ingersoll Rand separated its Industrial and. Better experience for our clients of service I share that only to express that we install a 14 American. In our company more access we have a lot of purchasing power reflects how much they cost assure... Long- if the best experience we could for our clients became an American. That into their cost of the story of how these brands, their,. Has been lowered this day and duct design is the installing HVAC contractor,! Not huge, is larger than the 3rd party supply houses sit down and compare Trane to their competition....